November 2026 published edition
Cities near Marco Island
Cities near Marco Island
Choose a city to explore. Closest first.
Top Real Estate Agents in Marco Island, FL
Based on Cribber’s trailing-12-month listing-activity data, Scott Needles Stacy Witthoff ranks first in Marco Island, FL with 105 credited listings.
Homes listed leaders: 1. Scott Needles Stacy Witthoff · 2. Michelle Thomas · 3. Mary Bartos And The Bartos Group
Asking volume leaders: 1. Michelle Thomas · 2. Scott Needles Stacy Witthoff · 3. Chris Sullivan
How rankings workHistorical snapshot. Open the latest leaderboard.
Nov 2, 2025 – Nov 2, 2026
Published cutoff
Scott Needles Stacy Witthoff · this edition
November 2026 edition · 484 agents · data through Nov 2, 2026.
Agent leaderboard
| Rank | Agent / team | Listing share | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| T-200 | Hagit TayarPremiere Plus Realty Co. | 1 | $399K | 0.06% listing share |
| T-200 | Debbie GardinerPremiere Plus Realty Co. | 1 | $395K | 0.06% listing share |
| T-200 | Ileana Bogaert, Realtor, Cips, Srs, Abr, Psa, Rene, Rsps, Ahwd, GriRe Max Affinity Plus | 1 | $386K | 0.06% listing share |
| T-200 | Matt DominyRoyal Shell Real Estate - Parkshore | 1 | $380K | 0.06% listing share |
| T-200 | Al CohoonPremiere Plus Realty Co. | 1 | $379K | 0.06% listing share |
| T-200 | Marty McguireReal Estate Of Florida | 1 | $379K | 0.06% listing share |
| T-200 | Pam AckerDalton Wade Inc | 1 | $375K | 0.06% listing share |
| T-200 | Dan SperdutoExp Realty, LLC | 1 | $370K | 0.06% listing share |
| T-200 | Deborah SchraderSchrader Realty Team, Inc. | 1 | $367K | 0.06% listing share |
| T-200 | Aimee MindaKeller Williams Realty - Marco Island | 1 | $350K | 0.06% listing share |
| T-200 | Thomas WiebellCall It Closed Intl Realty | 1 | $350K | 0.06% listing share |
| T-200 | Darlene CaseyKeller Wiliams, LLC | 1 | $345K | 0.06% listing share |
| T-200 | Michael GiustoMDM Naples Real Estate LLC | 1 | $345K | 0.06% listing share |
| T-200 | Mike DownerColdwell Banker Realty | 1 | $335K | 0.06% listing share |
| T-200 | Geoff FahringerDowning-Frye Realty | 1 | $320K | 0.06% listing share |
| T-200 | Christina Muracco LLCPremier Sotheby'S International Realty | 1 | $320K | 0.06% listing share |
| T-200 | Robert CuccinelloHomes And Land Brokers Inc | 1 | $319K | 0.06% listing share |
| T-200 | Jennifer SchmalingKeller Williams Realty - Marco Island | 1 | $310K | 0.06% listing share |
| T-200 | Ann StuartPremiere Plus Realty Co. | 1 | $299K | 0.06% listing share |
| T-200 | John GacosKeller Williams Realty - Marco Island | 1 | $299K | 0.06% listing share |
Showing 441–460 of 484 agents
Understanding these numbers ↓Ranks are calculated across all 484 agents. Tied agents share a rank, including across pages.
Reading the rankings
- Listings
- Distinct qualifying homes credited to an agent or team during the reporting window. Current and past listings contribute under the same rules; co-listing agents each receive credit.
- Asking volume
- The combined selected observed asking prices of credited homes. A volume rank requires a usable asking price for every qualifying home.
About the data
November 2026 edition
- Reporting window
- –
- Coverage
- 484 agents & teams · 1,725 unique homes
- Published
- Data cutoff
Updated monthly.
Sources & reuse
Cite this leaderboard
Cribber. Top Real Estate Agents in Marco Island, FL. November 2026 edition. Listings and asking volume, Nov 2, 2025–Nov 2, 2026. Published Nov 12, 2026.
Leaderboard downloads
The same dated edition, ready to read or analyze.
Markdown is readable text. JSON includes ranking data, dates, definitions, and evidence links.
What changed this month?
Homes Listed ranks compared with October 2026. Counts can change as older listings leave the rolling window; they are not listings added this month.
- Scott Needles Stacy WitthoffRank 1 → 1 · 105 → 105 credited listings
- Michelle ThomasRank 2 → 2 · 81 → 81 credited listings
- Mary Bartos And The Bartos GroupRank 3 → 3 · 66 → 65 credited listings
- Chris SullivanRank 4 → 4 · 62 → 61 credited listings
- Paul TateoRank 5 → 5 · 36 → 35 credited listings
- Cathy RogersRank 6 → 6 · 26 → 26 credited listings
- Patrick WilkinsRank 6 → 7 · 26 → 25 credited listings
- Jim PrangeRank 8 → 8 · 23 → 23 credited listings
- Laurie ZoerbRank 9 → 9 · 22 → 22 credited listings
- Helen DonaghyRank 10 → 10 · 21 → 21 credited listings
Leaderboard editions
Explore the published monthly record.