October 2026 published edition
Historical snapshot. Open the latest leaderboard.
October 2026 published edition
Oct 26, 2025 – Oct 26, 2026
Published cutoff
Scott Needles Stacy Witthoff · this edition
October 2026 edition · 489 agents · data through Oct 26, 2026.
| Rank | Agent / team | Homes listed | Asking volume | Listing share |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Scott Needles Stacy WitthoffJohn R. Wood Properties | 105 homes · $145M | $145M | 6.01% listing share |
| 2 | Michelle ThomasPremier Sotheby'S International Realty | 81 homes · $183.2M | $183.2M | 4.64% listing share |
| 3 | Mary Bartos And The Bartos GroupPremiere Plus Realty Co. | 66 homes · $74.1M | $74.1M | 3.78% listing share |
| 4 | Chris SullivanRe Max Affinity Plus | 62 homes · $104.1M | $104.1M | 3.55% listing share |
| 5 | Paul TateoHorizons By The Sea, Inc | 36 homes · $53.4M | $53.4M | 2.06% listing share |
| T-6 | Cathy RogersPremier Sotheby'S International Realty | 26 homes · $86.7M | $86.7M | 1.49% listing share |
| T-6 | Patrick WilkinsRe Max Affinity Plus | 26 homes · $71M | $71M | 1.49% listing share |
| 8 | Jim PrangePremier Sotheby'S International Realty | 23 homes · $61.2M | $61.2M | 1.32% listing share |
| 9 | Laurie ZoerbJohn R. Wood Properties | 22 homes · $19.2M | $19.2M | 1.26% listing share |
| 10 | Helen DonaghyEngel & Volkers Marco Island | 21 homes · $15.1M | $15.1M | 1.20% listing share |
| T-11 | Natalie KirsteinWilliam Raveis Real Estate | 18 homes · $53.3M | $53.3M | 1.03% listing share |
| T-11 | Kristina LambrosKeller Williams Realty - Marco Island | 18 homes · $15.9M | $15.9M | 1.03% listing share |
| T-11 | Todd Lawler Emily PetersPremiere Plus Realty Co. | 18 homes · $14.3M | $14.3M | 1.03% listing share |
| T-14 | Wendy MccartyKeller Williams Realty - Marco Island | 17 homes · $31.2M | $31.2M | 0.97% listing share |
| T-14 | Mary Jo O'ReganPremier Sotheby'S International Realty | 17 homes · $20.4M | $20.4M | 0.97% listing share |
| T-16 | Larry CarusoPremier Sotheby'S International Realty | 15 homes · $47.7M | $47.7M | 0.86% listing share |
| T-16 | Tammi Vance P.ARe Max Affinity Plus | 15 homes · $11.5M | $11.5M | 0.86% listing share |
| T-18 | Devin SweazyPremier Sotheby'S International Realty | 14 homes · $34.2M | $34.2M | 0.80% listing share |
| T-18 | Reilly McgregorHarborview Realty Inc | 14 homes · $25.8M | $25.8M | 0.80% listing share |
| T-18 | Michele RoseRe Max Affinity Plus | 14 homes · $19M | $19M | 0.80% listing share |
Showing 1–20 of 489 agents
Understanding these numbers ↓Ranks are calculated across all 489 agents. Tied agents share a rank, including across pages.
About the data
Updated monthly.
Sources & reuse
Cribber. Top Real Estate Agents in Marco Island, FL. October 2026 edition. Listings and asking volume, Oct 26, 2025–Oct 26, 2026. Published Oct 26, 2026.
The same dated edition, ready to read or analyze.
Markdown is readable text. JSON includes ranking data, dates, definitions, and evidence links.
Explore the published monthly record.
Market Intelligence
ZIPs associated with Marco Island
The average asking price for Marco Island was $1,704,336 in October 2026, up 4.5% from September 2026.
See the Marco Island housing report