Cities near Sanibel

Choose a city to explore. Closest first.

Nov 2026 edition · Data through Nov 2, 2026 · Edition details

Top Real Estate Agents in Sanibel, FL

Name: Top Real Estate Agents in Sanibel, FL | Cribber
Creator: Cribber
Published: 2026-11-12T00:03:27.82965+00:00
License: https://cribber.ai/terms#ai-access

Based on Cribber’s trailing-12-month listing-activity data, Eric Pfeifer ranks first in Sanibel, FL with 67 credited listings.

Homes listed leaders: 1. Eric Pfeifer · 2. Phaidra Mcdermott · 3. Jeffrey Burns

Asking volume leaders: 1. Eric Pfeifer · 2. Phaidra Mcdermott · 3. Jeffrey Burns

How rankings work

Agents ranked

204

November 2026 published edition

Unique homes listed

889

Nov 2, 2025 – Nov 2, 2026

Data through

Nov 2, 2026

Published cutoff

Most homes listed

Eric Pfeifer · this edition

November 2026 edition · 204 agents · data through Nov 2, 2026.

Agent leaderboard

Agents in Sanibel
Rank	Agent / team			Listing share
T-101	Kathleen WaiteKeller Williams Realty Fort Myers And The Islands	1	$400K	0.11% listing share
T-101	Colby HeuseveldtSteelbridge Realty LLC	1	$319K	0.11% listing share
T-101	Carol Robbins 239-287-6905Mobile Home Lady	1	$198K	0.11% listing share
T-101	Antonette FazlicShe Sells Florida LLC	1	$100K	0.11% listing share

Showing 201–204 of 204 agents

Understanding these numbers ↓

Ranks are calculated across all 204 agents. Tied agents share a rank, including across pages.

Market Intelligence

Sanibel market snapshot

ZIPs associated with Sanibel

Active listings during month · ZIPs associated with Sanibel: 417Oct 2026
Average asking price · ZIPs associated with Sanibel: $1,331,887Oct 2026
Average days on market · ZIPs associated with Sanibel: 137.6 daysOct 2026

The average asking price for Sanibel was $1,331,887 in October 2026, up 4.2% from September 2026.

See the Sanibel housing report

Reading the rankings

Listings: Distinct qualifying homes credited to an agent or team during the reporting window. Current and past listings contribute under the same rules; co-listing agents each receive credit.
Asking volume: The combined selected observed asking prices of credited homes. A volume rank requires a usable asking price for every qualifying home.
Observed listing share: Credited homes ÷ 889 unique homes in this leaderboard. Co-listing credits overlap, so shares can total more than 100%. The denominator is this edition’s qualifying homes.

About the data

November 2026 edition

Reporting window: Nov 2, 2025 – Nov 2, 2026
Coverage: 204 agents & teams · 889 unique homes
Published: Nov 12, 2026, 12:03 AM UTC
Data cutoff: Nov 2, 2026, 3:39 AM UTC

Updated monthly.

Sources & reuse

Cite this leaderboard

Cribber. Top Real Estate Agents in Sanibel, FL. November 2026 edition. Listings and asking volume, Nov 2, 2025–Nov 2, 2026. Published Nov 12, 2026.

Permanent edition link ↗

Leaderboard downloads

The same dated edition, ready to read or analyze.

ListingsMarkdown JSON
Asking volumeMarkdown JSON

Markdown is readable text. JSON includes ranking data, dates, definitions, and evidence links.

What changed this month?

Homes Listed ranks compared with October 2026. Counts can change as older listings leave the rolling window; they are not listings added this month.

Eric PfeiferRank 1 → 1 · 67 → 67 credited listings
Phaidra McdermottRank 2 → 2 · 50 → 48 credited listings
Jeffrey BurnsRank 3 → 3 · 43 → 43 credited listings
Susan MccallionRank 4 → 4 · 35 → 35 credited listings
Karen Bell & The Bell TeamRank 4 → 5 · 35 → 33 credited listings
Jennifer McsorleyRank 6 → 6 · 32 → 32 credited listings
Kelly HugueninRank 7 → 7 · 31 → 31 credited listings
Teresa BakerRank 8 → 8 · 23 → 23 credited listings
Kerri MawRank 8 → 8 · 23 → 23 credited listings
Wendy KirschnerRank 10 → 10 · 18 → 18 credited listings

Leaderboard editions

Explore the published monthly record.